Reporting cutoff: November 16, 2026. Each issue reflects the public record as of its cutoff date; later developments appear in later issues.
Issue No. 15 — November 16, 2026
In this issue: post-trial loyalty findings against a founder, a charter ruling on asset-sale proceeds, and a Section 220 fee ruling.
Lead Matter
Sarwal v. NephroSant, Inc. — court finds, after trial, that a founder and former chief executive breached the duty of loyalty (Del. Ch. Nov. 12, 2026, C.A. No. 2023-0222-BWD)
NephroSant, Inc. was founded in 2017 by Dr. Minnie Sarwal and two others to develop diagnostic tests from intellectual property created in her UCSF laboratory; QSant is a urine test assessing kidney-transplant rejection risk. Sarwal, formerly its chief executive and a director, sought indemnification for a special committee investigation; the company counterclaimed for breach of fiduciary duty. After a two-day trial in May 2026, Vice Chancellor David found that Sarwal and the laboratory directors removed clusterin from the QSant algorithm while the company's MolDX submissions described a six-biomarker test, without informing the other directors; that after the committee's counsel directed her not to delete documents, she downloaded 33,000 files and deleted more than 15,000 from her NephroSant Box account; and that she solicited investors for a competing venture that did not progress. It rejected her account that advisers authorized the deletions, while noting that her patient-data concerns were not entirely manufactured. The court found that each of those acts breached her duty of loyalty, drew adverse inferences where evidence was incomplete and deletion reasonably inferred, and awarded NephroSant $7,952,683.84 in damages and the costs of briefing the sanctions motion and retaining a forensic expert, in an amount to be determined; it denied indemnification. The court rejected the company's $100 million damages model because its six-biomarker counterfactual was unsupported.
On The Docket
Assad v. Clark (Huckleberry.ai, f/k/a Domo) — charter held to require distribution of asset-sale proceeds (Del. Ch. Nov. 10, 2026, C.A. No. 2026-1264-BWD)
On July 22, 2026, Domo, Inc., since renamed Huckleberry.ai, Inc., agreed to sell substantially all its assets to Progress Software Corporation for about $400 million; it retained more than $900 million of net operating loss carryforwards, which the parties agree are not available for distribution. Founder and chief executive Joshua James, holding 75.7 percent of the voting power as of July 22, approved the sale by written consent. The company disclosed that it did not intend to liquidate after closing and that the board would evaluate alternatives for the proceeds. The sale closed September 22; a stockholder sued two days later. On cross-motions for summary judgment, Vice Chancellor David held that the charter's Liquidation Event provision, Article V, Section 4, unambiguously requires distribution of assets legally available for distribution pro rata to common stockholders, rejected the defendants' laches defense, and left identifying the legally available assets to the board in the first instance.
Also Tracking
Bernstein v. MyJoVE — Nov. 9 letter opinion (Del. Ch., C.A. No. 2026-0301-DH (LWW)) adopting an unchallenged recommendation to enter judgment against a co-founder in a Section 220 suit based on a release; the court did not endorse the release rationale and denied the company's request for fees • In re Cloudflare — the Delaware Supreme Court accepted the interlocutory appeal from the Oct. 16 injunction on Nov. 6 and expedited it (No. 468, 2026); briefing closes Dec. 16.
About the Docket. The VC Litigation Docket is educational; it is not legal or investment advice, and it does not create any advisory or attorney-client relationship. Matters are selected for structural significance, not recency; coverage is limited to matters with documented court filings and rulings and is not comprehensive. Allegations are reported as allegations; interim rulings are identified as interim rulings. The Docket reports court rulings and attributed allegations; it does not make independent findings of fact or predict case outcomes. Counsel references are docket information; the Docket does not rank, rate, endorse, or recommend counsel. The editor serves as a testifying and consulting expert in venture capital and private-company disputes. Except as disclosed in Corrections and Clarifications, neither the editor nor VC Expert Services LLC has been retained or approached in connection with the matters identified in this issue, and neither has identified a conflict concerning those matters. Corrections and clarifications are published in the following issue and recorded on the Corrections and Clarifications page at vcexpertservices.com/docket; archived issues are not silently revised. Issues are published at vcexpertservices.com/docket.
VC Expert Services LLC, providing expert witness and litigation consulting in venture capital and private-company disputes. P.O. Box 3236, Saratoga, CA 95070 • vcexpertservices.com.